I recently had cause to read a helpful summary of a decision by the South Australian Supreme Court in the matter of Allied Distribution Finance Pty Ltd v Samwise Holdings Pty Ltd [2017] SASC 163. While much of the background to the case is a little fiddly, I’ll give a short ‘broad strokes’ summary in order to help demonstrate why this might be a very useful decision for the hire industry.
For those wanting a more detailed look, I recommend the summary HERE or, for those that want a real thrill, the full text of the judgment can be found HERE.
The case concerned Bill’s Motorcycles – a dealer, selling and servicing Kawasaki motorcycles. Bill’s had been financing its floor stock with one financier but then struck an agreement with another (Allied Distribution Finance – ADF). Bill’s stock of 40 motorcycles (secured by the original financier) was bought out by Kawasaki and, effectively, sold to ADF. Bill’s maintained possession of the motorcycles and ADF lodged a PMSI registration on the PPSR to perfect its security interest over them.
When Bill’s went into administration a couple of months later, there was a dispute concerning those 40 motorcycles between Samwise, the holder of a General Security Interest (AllPAAP) over all Bill’s assets and ADF as a PMSI holder.
While a PMSI will usually take priority over an AllPAAP, in this case, Samwise argued that because Bill’s was already in possession of the motorcycles at the time ADF lodged their PMSI registration, ADF had failed to meet the time-scale requirements of section 62 of the PPSA.
Section 62, effectively, states that, in order to achieve PMSI priority over inventory items, a registration must be lodged before the grantor obtains possession of the property.
Samwise argued that, as Bill’s had already been in possession of the motorcycles for some time before ADF lodged their registration, ADF was not entitled to PMSI priority.
In his judgment, Justice Blue determined that, in the overall context, the implication of section 62 should be taken to mean that the registration must be lodged before the grantor obtains the type of possession that would entitle them to grant a PMSI interest in the property.
Thus it is the grantor’s possession in the role of PMSI grantor that matters, rather than their mere physical possession of the property.
While this is unlikely to be of any assistance to trade credit suppliers forgetting to perfect their Retention of Title rights in time, it may have implications for the long-term hire industry.
Last year, the Government made changes to the manner in which hires and leases were caught up by the PPSA. In short, the changes involved leases for less than 2 years no longer needing to be registered on the PPSR. Where a lease was established for an indefinite period that may or may not extend beyond 2 years, the new legislation only required a registration to be put in place once that 2-year limit was breached.
When I posted about the new legislation, I wrote:
In order to be eligible for PMSI super priority where the collateral being used is designated as a non-inventory item, the perfecting registration must be lodged within 15 business days of the lessee taking possession of the property.
However, where an indefinite lease is concerned and the lessor doesn’t lodge their registration until it becomes clear the lease may extend beyond the new 2 year qualifying period, that 15 business days period may long since have passed leaving the lessor’s claim to their equipment to fall behind those of other general security holders with registrations already in place.
Justice Blue’s decision in the Bill’s Motorcycles case suggests that, while a lessee may have been in physical possession of property for 729 days, it will only be at the 2 year mark they have possession in the capacity of a grantor of a PMSI right and it should, therefore, be at that 2 year point when the PPSA’s 15 business days countdown for a PMSI eligible registration should commence.
Whether this interpretation is sufficient to also satisfy the Corporations Act’s dreaded section 588FL is another matter!
